If you’re looking at the Sandy’s Pizza menu for the first time, here’s the short version: it’s a family-run pizzeria in Fort Branch, Indiana (with a sister location in Princeton), known for hand-stretched pizza in five sizes, a homemade stromboli that regulars talk about more than the pizza itself, smoked and fried wings in nine flavors, two standout salads, and a pizza-pasta-salad buffet that runs most days of the week. The dining room has a 50s-diner feel, complete with a train that rumbles past behind the building.
This guide walks through every category on the menu, what each item actually tastes like, current pricing where it’s publicly listed, and which dishes are worth your money. It’s updated for 2026 and written by someone who dug through the real menu, the official site, delivery platforms, and customer feedback to put this together, not someone guessing from a logo and a stock photo.
One thing up front: this is an independent, unofficial guide to Sandy’s Pizza. It isn’t affiliated with, endorsed by, or run by the restaurant. Menus, hours, and prices change without notice, so treat every number here as a solid starting point, not a guarantee.
Quick Overview: What’s on the Sandy’s Pizza Menu
Sandy’s Pizza serves five categories worth knowing before you order: pizza (five sizes, classic and specialty), stromboli (their signature item, in 6-inch and footlong), wings (traditional, boneless, and dry-rubbed), salads (two house recipes), and sandwiches on the same homemade bun used for the stromboli. A daily buffet (“smorgasbord”) combines pizza, pasta, and a salad bar for one price. Beer, root beer, and soft drinks round out the drink list, with soft-serve style ice cream for dessert.
Pizza Menu and Prices
Sandy’s pizza starts with a hand-stretched, homemade crust and their own sauce recipe. The crust holds up under heavy toppings without turning soggy in the middle, which is more common than you’d think at buffet-style pizzerias.
Pizzas come in five sizes, and the size chart on the menu doubles as a handy ordering guide for group size:
| Size | Serves | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Small (7″) | 1 adult | $10.30 |
| Medium (10″) | 2 adults | $13.90 |
| Large (14″) | 3–4 adults | $26.00 |
| Party (20″) | 4–6 adults | $41.45 |
| Giant (30″) | 11–15 adults | $73.64 |
Toppings are added a la carte on top of a cheese base, so a loaded specialty pizza will run higher than the base prices above.
Specialty Pizzas Worth Ordering
Barbeque Chicken Pizza — Grilled chicken, sweet barbeque sauce, crispy fried onions, and jalapenos. This one leans sweet-and-smoky first, with the jalapenos showing up as a slow heat after a few bites rather than an upfront burn. Good pick if your group has mixed spice tolerance.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza — Grilled chicken, bacon, and a ranch base instead of red sauce. You can swap in buffalo sauce for a spicier version, which regulars order more often than the plain ranch base.
Chicken Artisan Pizza — A garlic butter crust topped with grilled chicken, spinach, tomato, mushroom, and feta. Out of everything on the specialty list, this is the most “restaurant” tasting pie, not a typical pizzeria offering, and it eats more like a flatbread than a traditional slice.
Hawaiian-Style Pizza — Cheese, ham, pineapple, and Sandy’s own sweet red peppers instead of the usual green bell pepper. The sweet red peppers are the thing locals mention over and over in reviews, and they genuinely change the flavor of a Hawaiian pie for the better, less bitter, more caramelized.
Stromboli-Topped Pizza — Cheese, stromboli sausage, green peppers, onion, sweet red peppers, and pepper rings. If you can’t decide between a stromboli and a pizza, this combines both.
Stromboli Menu
Ask a regular what to order at Sandy’s and stromboli comes up before pizza almost every time. It’s built on the same homemade bun as the sandwiches, piled with Italian sausage, pepper rings, green peppers, onion, and a thick slice of mozzarella, then baked with pizza sauce folded in.
| Item | Size | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Stromboli | 6″ | $5.50 |
| Stromboli | Footlong | $11.38 |
| Sweet BBQ Stromboli | 6″ | $6.25 |
| Sweet BBQ Stromboli | Footlong | $12.75 |
The Sweet BBQ version swaps the pizza sauce for sweet barbeque sauce, keeping the same sausage-and-pepper base. It’s less messy to eat than the original, since the BBQ sauce is thicker and stays put inside the bun instead of dripping.
A 6-inch stromboli is really a one-person lunch portion. The footlong is meant to be split, or taken home for a second meal, since it’s dense enough that finishing it solo is a challenge.
Wings Menu
Wings at Sandy’s come three ways: traditional bone-in, boneless, and dry-rubbed. Flavor options span nine varieties, which is a wide range for a pizzeria this size.
Flavors available: BBQ, Teriyaki, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet & Spicy BBQ, Asian Zing, Garlic Buffalo, Classic Buffalo, Honey Hot, and Mango Habanero.
| Wing Style | Portion | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional Bone-In | Regular (6) | $10.00 |
| Traditional Bone-In | Family (12) | $19.00 |
| Traditional Bone-In | Party (24) | $36.00 |
| Boneless | (8) | $10.25 |
| Boneless | (16) | $19.50 |
| Boneless | (24) | $28.50 |
Dry rubs are also available for a lighter, less messy alternative to sauced wings, with flavors like Cowboy Seasoning, Honey Bacon BBQ, Lemon Pepper, and Garlic Jalapeno, each served with a dipping sauce (Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Italian Butter, Honey Mustard, or Ranch).
If you’re ordering for a group with different spice preferences, Garlic Parmesan and Honey Hot tend to satisfy the widest range of tastes, one leans savory, the other sweet-with-a-kick, and neither is aggressively hot.
Salads
Two house salads show up repeatedly in customer reviews, and both go well beyond the usual iceberg-and-tomato buffet salad.
Chicken Cranberry Salad — Lettuce and spinach with grilled chicken, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, feta cheese, purple onion, and a raspberry walnut vinaigrette. The dressing is on the sweeter side, so it pairs well against a savory pizza order rather than as a stand-alone light meal.
Strawberry Spinach Pecan Salad — Spinach, pecans, strawberries, oranges, purple onion, feta, bacon, croutons, and poppy seed dressing. This is the fuller of the two salads, closer to a meal than a side, thanks to the bacon and pecans adding real texture and protein.
Both salads are also available on the buffet’s salad bar, so you can build your own version if you want a smaller portion or fewer toppings.
Sandwiches
Built on the same homemade bun as the stromboli, the sandwich menu is smaller but solid.
Ham & Cheese Sandwich (Footlong) — Simple, but the bun makes the difference here. Some reviewers found it a touch garlicky, so if you’re sensitive to garlic butter on the crust, ask for it on the side.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich — Grilled chicken on a toasted footlong bun with crisp bacon. Straightforward, but the bacon adds enough crunch to keep it from feeling plain.
Sandy’s Combo Sandwich — Italian sausage, pepperoni, smoked ham, mushroom, onion, green peppers, sliced tomato, mozzarella, and a house sauce, all on the footlong bun. This is the one to order if you want everything on the menu piled into a single sandwich.
The Smorgasbord Buffet
Sandy’s runs a buffet, called the Smorgasbord, that combines a rotating pizza selection, a pasta bar, and a full salad bar for one flat price. It’s popular with families and larger groups because everyone can build their own plate instead of agreeing on one pizza order.
Customers have reported paying around $20 for two adults with a small combination pizza, two salad bar plates, and drinks, though buffet pricing depends on the day and current promotions, so confirm current buffet pricing before you go, since it isn’t listed publicly with the same consistency as the a la carte menu.
The pizza selection on the buffet line rotates through a handful of the specialty pies rather than offering every option at once, and it moves fast during dinner rush, so pies come out hot and get replaced quickly rather than sitting under a heat lamp.
Drinks and Dessert
Sandy’s keeps its own root beer on the menu, and it’s mentioned by name in reviews more than any other drink on the list, including from truckers who’ve stopped in off the highway. Diet Mt. Dew is also stocked, along with the usual soft drink lineup, and beer is available for dine-in customers looking to pair a cold one with a hot pizza.
For dessert, soft-serve style ice cream is served in a cup, cake cone, or waffle cone, with flavors including Madagascar Vanilla Bean. You can also add a scoop to a soda for a float, or on top of a warm dessert for an a la mode finish.
What to Order: Best Picks and What to Skip
If it’s your first visit, start with the stromboli, either the original or the Sweet BBQ version, since it’s the item Sandy’s is genuinely known for in the area, not just a menu filler. Pair it with the Strawberry Spinach Pecan Salad if you want something lighter alongside it.
For groups, the Party or Giant pizza with the boneless wings covers the most ground without ordering ten different things. Garlic Parmesan and BBQ wings tend to disappear first at group orders.
Skip ordering a plain cheese pizza if you’re trying the specialty options for the first time. It’s fine, but it doesn’t showcase what makes this menu different from any other local pizzeria, namely the sweet red peppers and the specialty sauces.
Healthier and Lighter Options
Neither salad is technically “light,” since both carry cheese, bacon, or a sweetened dressing, but they’re still the lowest-calorie route through the menu compared to a full pizza order. If you want to keep the meal lighter, order the salad with dressing on the side and split a small stromboli rather than a full pizza.
Vegetarian options are limited. The Hawaiian-style pizza minus the ham, or a plain cheese pizza with mushroom, onion, and green pepper added, are the most realistic vegetarian routes on this menu. There’s no dedicated plant-based or dairy-free section listed.
Sandy’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Sandy’s Pizza is not one big chain. The name belongs to separate local spots, and each has its own menu and pricing. That is why one price list does not fit every location.
Here is what to expect in general:
- Pizza: classic pies, specialty pies, and thin crust
- Handheld food: calzones, strombolis, subs, and wraps
- Sides and extras: appetizers, soups, salads, and drinks
[ADD PRICE TABLE: pizza sizes, toppings, calzone, stromboli from the official menu]
Pizza prices usually rise with size and extra toppings. Call the store for today’s price.
Sandy’s Pizza Menu Near Me
The easiest way to find the closest store is a map search for “Sandy’s Pizza.” Many shops share the name, so check the address before you order.
Two locations show up clearly in public listings:
| Location | Address | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| Fort Branch, IN | 609 S Main St, Fort Branch, IN 47648 | (812) 753-3972 |
| East Brunswick, NJ | 322 Rues Ln, East Brunswick, NJ 08816 | 732-254-1313 Sandy’s Pizza +3 |
If you are in a different city, call first to confirm the shop is open and serves the menu you want.
Sandy’s Pizza Menu Fort Branch, IN
The Fort Branch shop sits at 609 S Main St. It is a casual, family-friendly spot. It offers delivery, takes credit cards, has a parking lot, and serves beer and wine. menupixmenupix
Hours listed online:
- Monday: 4:00 pm to 10:00 pm menupix
- Tuesday to Thursday and Sunday: 10:30 am to 10:00 pm menupix
- Friday and Saturday: 10:30 am to 11:00 pm menupix
What do reviewers say? The rating is 3.0 stars from 33 reviews. Feedback is mixed. Several guests praise the pizza itself, while some mention uneven service. If you want a quick meal, call ahead and ask about wait times. menupix
[ADD PRICE TABLE: Fort Branch pizza sizes and specialty pies]
Sandy’s Pizza Menu Houston
We could not find a verified Sandy’s Pizza location in Houston, Texas. Search results for this phrase mostly showed other Houston pizza shops, not a Sandy’s.
If you are looking for Sandy’s in Houston:
- Check the exact spelling and address on a map listing.
- Call the restaurant and ask for a current menu.
- Be careful with third-party sites that copy menu text without a real source.
If you still want pizza in Houston, many local shops list their menus on delivery apps. Just make sure the name and address match the place you want.
Sandy’s Deli Menu
The deli side of Sandy’s is easiest to see at the East Brunswick store. Its delivery listing shows a long deli-style menu. Categories include club sandwiches, honey wheat wraps, burgers, signature sandwiches, deli platters, hot and cold subs in half and whole sizes, and paninis. ubereats
Easy picks if you skip pizza:
- Subs: choose half or whole, hot or cold
- Wraps: a lighter handheld option
- Deli platters: better for groups
- Soups and salads: quick sides or a light meal
[ADD PRICE TABLE: subs, wraps, platters from the official deli menu]
Sandy’s East Brunswick Menu
The East Brunswick shop at 322 Rues Ln works like a diner and pizzeria in one. The menu is wide. The delivery listing shows breakfast items like eggs, omelettes, pancakes, French toast, and waffles, along with soups, salads, pasta, entrees, and sides. atlyubereats
Pizza and baked items:
- Regular pizzas ubereats
- Whole wheat pizza ubereats
- Sandy’s Famous Thin Crust Pizza ubereats
- Calzone and stromboli ubereats
- Al forno pasta ubereats
Hours: Sources do not fully agree. One delivery listing shows 8:00 AM to 9:30 PM daily. Another shows 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Call 732-254-1313 to confirm before you go. 8abd1d3e 17eb 5632 a449 59641c41246e +2
One guest review notes that takeout calzones and slices are large, and that lunch can get busy. Ordering ahead can save time. atlyatly
Sandy’s Pizza Fort Branch
For the quickest facts on the Fort Branch shop:
- Address: 609 S Main St, Fort Branch, IN 47648 menupix
- Phone: (812) 753-3972 menupix
- Delivery: Yes menupix
- Good for kids: Yes menupix
- Price level: $$ (mid-range) menupix
It ranks well locally. It is listed as number one of four pizza places in Fort Branch. That makes it a safe pick for a family pizza night, as long as you plan for a possible wait on busy evenings. menupix
Sandy’s East Brunswick Menu With Prices
Prices at the East Brunswick shop are not shown in a consistent public source. Delivery app prices are often higher than in-store prices, so compare both before you order.
Tips to save money:
- Order direct by phone or the shop’s site when possible
- Ask about lunch specials
- Share a large pizza or platter for groups
How We Verified This Menu
This guide was put together by cross-checking Sandy’s Pizza’s official website menu pages, third-party delivery listings, and recent customer photos and reviews from the Fort Branch and Princeton, Indiana locations. Prices reflect what was publicly listed at the time of writing and may not match every location or every promotional period. We did not call the restaurant directly to confirm every line item, so treat the pricing here as a strong reference point rather than a final quote.
Prices vary by location, franchise, and season. Always confirm current pricing and item availability at your nearest Sandy’s Pizza location or through their official ordering channels before placing a large order.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Sandy’s Pizza known for?
Sandy’s Pizza is best known for its homemade stromboli and its use of sweet red peppers as a signature topping, both of which show up across multiple menu items and get mentioned repeatedly in customer reviews.
How much is a large pizza at Sandy’s Pizza?
A large (14-inch) pizza at Sandy’s Pizza is listed at $26.00, which serves roughly 3 to 4 adults, before adding extra toppings.
Does Sandy’s Pizza have a buffet?
Yes. Sandy’s runs a Smorgasbord buffet combining pizza, a pasta bar, and a salad bar for a flat price, with pricing that can vary by day and location.
Does Sandy’s Pizza deliver?
Sandy’s Pizza offers delivery from its Fort Branch, Indiana location, including to nearby areas like Princeton and Owensville, and is also listed on third-party delivery platforms in some markets.
Is there a vegetarian option at Sandy’s Pizza?
Vegetarian choices are limited to a customizable cheese pizza or a Hawaiian-style pizza without ham, since there’s no dedicated vegetarian section on the current menu.
What are Sandy’s Pizza’s hours?
Hours vary by location. At the Fort Branch, Indiana location, typical hours run Monday 4:00 PM–10:00 PM, Tuesday through Thursday 10:00 AM/10:30 AM–10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday 10:30 AM–11:00 PM, and Sunday 10:30 AM–10:00 PM. Confirm hours directly before visiting, as they can shift by season.
Final Word
The Sandy’s Pizza menu holds up because of a few specific things done well: a homemade bun that carries both the stromboli and the sandwiches, a sweet red pepper topping you won’t find at most chain pizzerias, and a buffet that makes it easy to feed a group without agreeing on one order. If you’re deciding where to start, order the stromboli first and build the rest of your meal around it. Go hungry, and bring cash if you’re planning to tip the delivery driver, since personal checks aren’t accepted in-store.
Irfan Khan is an experienced writer and researcher with over 6 years of expertise in Manu-related topics. Through ManuLibrary, he shares reliable information, insightful updates, and valuable knowledge to help readers explore, understand, and discover everything about Manu.
