The Big Apple Pizzeria menu is built around New York-style pizza, and it goes well beyond that. Expect big slices, whole pies, calzones, wings, subs, wraps, pasta dinners and a few desserts. Which items you get depends on the shop, because several independent pizzerias use this name across the US.
This guide covers what the menu offers, what each section is like, and what to order first. Last updated: September 2026.
This is an independent, unofficial guide. ManuPoint.com is not affiliated with any Big Apple Pizzeria location.
Big Apple Pizzeria Menu at a Glance
- Core item: large New York-style slices and whole pies
- Specialty pizzas: gourmet pies, white pizza, BBQ chicken, buffalo chicken
- Diet-friendly options: gluten-free crust and vegan pizza at some shops
- Beyond pizza: calzones, wings, garlic knots, salads, subs, wraps, burgers, gyros, baked pasta
- Sweet finish: cheesecake, cannoli, fried dough with powdered sugar (varies by shop)
- Ordering: dine-in, takeout, delivery, and online ordering platforms
Which Big Apple Pizzeria Are We Talking About?
There is no single national chain with this name in the US. You will find independent shops called Big Apple Pizzeria or Big Apple Pizza in places like Troy (NY), Virginia Beach (VA), Utah and Florida. Each one writes its own menu and sets its own prices.
There is also an unrelated Israeli chain called Big Apple Pizza, founded in 1986. It was started by a man who had spent years in New York City and wanted to bring thin-crust NYC pizza to Israel. That business has no link to the American shops covered here.
The categories below follow what these shops commonly list. Where a detail belongs to one location, we say so.
How We Verified This Menu
We checked publicly posted menus from several Big Apple Pizzeria and Big Apple Pizza shops. Sources were the shops’ own websites and their listings on online ordering platforms, reviewed in September 2026.
We did not invent prices or calorie counts. Where a price appears, it comes from a specific shop’s posted menu and is labeled as such. Most of these shops do not publish calorie data.
Prices vary by location, franchise, and season. Confirm at your nearest store or the official app or website before ordering.
Pizza by the Slice
The slice is the reason many people walk in. At the Utah location, a slice is cut from an 18-inch New York-style pie and is available until 7 pm. That is a big slice, and for most adults it works as a full lunch when paired with a drink.
The slice board at that shop looks like this:
| Slice | What’s on it | Posted price (Utah shop) |
|---|---|---|
| New York Slice | Cheese, with toppings of your choice | $6.25 |
| Vegetarian Slice | Onion, green pepper, mushroom, black olive, diced tomato | $5.75 |
| Combo Slice | Pepperoni, ham, salami, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, black olive | $6.25 |
| Hawaiian Slice | Canadian bacon and pineapple | $6.25 |
| Slaughterhouse Slice | Pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball | $6.25 |
Source: the Utah location’s posted menu. Other shops price differently.
The Combo is the most balanced choice if you like a bit of everything. The Slaughterhouse is meat on meat on meat, so it suits a big appetite, and it can feel heavy alongside a side order. If you are new to the menu, start with a plain New York Slice. It shows you how the crust folds, how the sauce tastes, and whether the shop is worth a return trip.
Slice supply thins out later in the evening at many pizzerias. If you want a specific slice, go earlier or ask the counter what just came out of the oven.
Whole Pizzas: Classic and Create-Your-Own
Most locations sell whole pies in a few sizes, with a cheese pie as the base. The Troy shop’s menu is organized around a “Create Your Own Pizza” section, plus separate sections for gourmet pies, gluten-free and vegan pizzas, and a choice between 12-cut and 24-cut pizzas.
The cut option is a small detail with real use. If you are feeding kids or a party, the 24-cut turns one pie into small, easy-to-share pieces. For two adults, the 12-cut is plenty.
A Florida location also lists a thin square pizza. It is topped with the shop’s tomato sauce and mozzarella. Square, thin pies tend to have a crackly edge and are easy to eat while chatting, which makes them a good pick for game night.
Classic toppings at these shops usually include pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, and extra cheese. One Florida menu also lists a meat-heavy option with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatballs, ham and extra cheese. If you want a loaded pie, skip adding more toppings on top of a specialty. Too many toppings can make the center soggy.
Gourmet and Specialty Pizzas
The specialty section is where the menu gets creative, and where the pizzas differ most from shop to shop. Here are the standouts we found across posted menus.
White Pizza with Fresh Mozzarella
Sauce-free pizza made with a white base. The Troy shop describes it with mozzarella, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, garlic, olive oil and fresh basil, on a white base, and it is vegetarian. It tastes lighter than a red-sauce pie and leans on garlic and basil. Choose this if you find tomato sauce too acidic.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Troy menu lists a pie with BBQ sauce, crispy chicken, mozzarella and tomato pizza sauce. It is sweet and smoky, and it pairs best with something crisp and unsweetened to drink, since the sauce already carries the sugar.
Honey Hot Chicken and Chicken Alfredo Broccoli
A menu summary for the Troy shop highlights the Honey Hot Chicken Pizza and the Chicken Alfredo Broccoli Pizza as signature gourmet offerings. The honey hot pie balances sweet and spicy. The alfredo-broccoli pie swaps tomato sauce for a creamy base, so it eats like a pasta dish on a crust. It is filling, so one or two slices go a long way.
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken shows up on several menus. A Troy listing names Classic Buffalo Chicken Pizza alongside cheese and pepperoni as a fan favorite. Pair it with a cooling side like ranch or a simple salad if you are sensitive to heat.
Margherita-Style and Vegetable Pies
The Fort Pierce, FL menu lists a pie with freshly sliced tomato, fresh basil, olive oil and Romano cheese, and another with mushrooms, red onion, green pepper, black olives and tomato. Both are good choices if you want a vegetarian order without going fully vegan.
Gluten-Free and Vegan Options
Some Big Apple Pizzeria shops offer gluten-free crust, and a few list vegan pizzas and calzones. At the Utah location, the gluten-free cheese pizza is a 9-inch rice flour crust with red sauce and mozzarella, priced at $12.50, and a Hawaiian version costs $14.10.
Gluten-free pies are small, so plan on one per person. The crust also tends to be crisper and less chewy than a wheat crust, which some people like better.
The Troy menu also lists a vegan pizza and calzone category and a separate vegan options section. Vegan cheese and toppings vary, so ask the shop what they use before ordering.
A note on allergies: a pizzeria kitchen handles flour, dairy, nuts and other allergens all day. If you have a serious allergy or celiac disease, tell the staff when ordering and ask directly about cross-contact. Do not rely on a menu label alone. Allergen information is not usually published online for these independent shops, so call ahead.
Calzones and Rolls
The Troy menu has separate sections for giant calzones and rolls, along with the vegan calzone option. A calzone is folded pizza dough filled with cheese and toppings, and it usually comes with marinara for dipping.
Calzones hold heat well, which makes them a smart pick for delivery. A pizza can lose its crispness in the box, while a calzone stays warm and soft inside. Ask what fillings are available at your shop, since ricotta and mozzarella are standard but meat and vegetable fillings vary.
Garlic Knots, Wings and Appetizers
Appetizers are worth a look, and garlic knots come up often in customer feedback. A summary of the Troy shop says customers rave about the garlic knots and the timely service. Garlic knots are soft, buttery, and made for dunking in marinara.
Wings are another common starter. The Troy menu describes them as served with crispy celery, carrot sticks and blue cheese dip. Order them mild if you plan to eat pizza after, since strong heat can dull the taste of everything else.
Other appetizers may include mozzarella sticks, fries and breadsticks with marinara. If you are ordering for a group, one garlic knots order plus one wings order usually covers the table before the pies arrive.
Fresh Salads
Salads at pizzerias often get skipped, but they can balance a heavy meal. A Florida menu lists a Caesar with grilled chicken, romaine lettuce and croutons in Caesar dressing. Many shops also sell salad dressing by the bottle.
A tossed salad is often bundled into lunch specials, which makes it a cheap way to add some greens without a separate charge.
Subs, Wraps, Burgers and Sandwiches
The menu runs well beyond pizza, and the Troy shop lists cold subs, oven-baked hot subs, wraps, and burgers and sandwiches as separate sections.
Cold subs on a North Palm Beach menu include an Italian-style combination with salami, ham, capicola, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepperoncini and black olives in a vinegar and oil dressing. It is tangy, salty and packed with meat.
Hot subs are baked, so the bread comes out crisp on the outside. Chicken parmigiana and meatball are standard pizzeria picks. Ask for a half if you are also ordering a side.
Wraps include turkey, ham and vegetable options. The Troy menu describes hearty wraps with turkey, ham and veggie choices, made with fresh ingredients. A wrap is a lighter option when a big sub feels like too much.
Burgers and sandwiches are on the Troy menu too, including a grilled chicken sandwich with lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese and mayonnaise.
Gyros and Over-Rice Platters
The Troy listing includes a gyros and over-rice platter section, a nod to the neighborhood-shop style where pizza shares the counter with Mediterranean staples. If you want something different from the usual pizzeria order, this is the section to check. Ask about sauce and portion size before you commit.
Baked Italian Dinners
The baked dinners are the comfort food part of the menu. The Troy listing describes a baked ziti with alfredo sauce, grilled chicken and mozzarella, served with garlic bread.
A North Palm Beach location lists eggplant rollatini, lasagna and ravioli as its favorite baked entrées. These dishes reheat well, so they make good leftovers. If you are feeding a family, one baked pasta plus one pizza is a solid mix.
Lunch Specials and Combos
Lunch deals are one of the best ways to save at a pizzeria. Two Florida shops list weekday lunch specials. One says its specials run Monday through Friday from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM and come with garlic knots, a tossed salad and a soft drink. The other lists weekday lunch combos, served 11am to 3pm, including lasagna, baked penne, spaghetti and meatballs, half subs, and slice-and-soda deals.
Lunch specials are a real value when they bundle a drink and a side. Compare the combo against ordering items separately, since the savings vary. Not every location runs them, so check hours and lunch times for your shop.
Desserts and Drinks
Dessert lists are short but classic. The Troy menu summary mentions New York-style cheesecake and cannoli. A North Palm Beach menu lists fried dough with powdered sugar. Cannoli is the lighter choice, and cheesecake is the richer one.
Drinks usually include fountain soda, bottled beverages, and brewed iced tea or coffee. Soda deals are often part of combos.
What to Order: Quick Picks by Craving
| If you want… | Try this |
|---|---|
| A fast lunch | A New York Slice with a drink |
| Something light | White pizza or a wrap |
| Big flavor | Honey hot chicken or BBQ chicken pizza |
| A veggie option | Vegetarian slice or a margherita-style pie |
| Comfort food | Baked ziti, lasagna or eggplant rollatini |
| A group meal | A 24-cut pie, garlic knots and wings |
| Gluten-free | A 9-inch gluten-free pie, after checking cross-contact |
Ordering Tips: Hours, Near Me, Deals and Secret Menu
Hours and near me. Each shop sets its own hours, so search for the location closest to you and check the current hours on its listing. Slice availability, lunch specials and delivery zones all differ by shop.
Deals. Weekday lunch specials are the most common deal. Some shops also run regular promotions on ordering platforms, which change often. Read the terms before you order.
Secret menu. We found no official secret menu at any Big Apple Pizzeria location. Some shops will build custom pies, so you can ask for a half-and-half or an extra topping. That is a standard pizzeria courtesy, not a hidden menu.
Online ordering. Several locations take orders through online platforms, with pickup and delivery options. Ordering ahead helps at busy times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Big Apple Pizza sell by the slice?
Yes, some Big Apple Pizza locations sell pizza by the slice, making it convenient for customers who want a quick meal. Availability may vary by location, along with the types of pizza and slice sizes offered. Check with your nearest restaurant for current slice options and prices.
How much is pizza for 2 people?
Pizza for two people typically costs around $15–$30 in the United States, depending on the restaurant and pizza size. A medium pizza is often enough for two people, especially when paired with a side or drink. Prices vary by toppings, crust type, location, and current deals.
How much does a 36-inch Big Guys pizza cost?
A 36-inch pizza from Big Guys! Pizza in the Philippines typically costs around ₱1,948–₱2,249, depending on the flavor.
foodpanda
+1
Cheese, pepperoni, Hawaiian, and all-meat options are available, with prices varying by toppings and branch.
foodpanda
+1Because prices and promotions can change, check the official Big Guys! Pizza menubefore ordering.
What’s the biggest size pizza you can get?
Some pizza restaurants offer exceptionally large pizzas measuring 36 inches across, including Big Guys! Pizza.
foodpanda
+1
A 36-inch pizza can provide more than 70 square-cut pieces and may serve approximately 10–15 people.
foodpanda
+1However, the biggest available size depends on the restaurant, so check its menu for oversized or party pizzas.
Final Word on the Big Apple Pizzeria Menu
The Big Apple Pizzeria menu works best when you match the item to your mood: a big slice for a quick lunch, a specialty pie for a group, a baked pasta for a comfort dinner. Start with a plain New York Slice to judge the shop, then branch into the gourmet pies. Check your local shop’s current prices and hours before you go, and come hungry.
Developer / CMS notes (no code):
- FAQPage schema for the FAQ section
- Article or BlogPosting schema with author, datePublished and dateModified (September 2026)
- BreadcrumbList schema: Home > Menus > Pizza > Big Apple Pizzeria Menu
- Menu/MenuItem structured data for the slice table only, if you keep it, and label it as a sample from one location
- Keep the visible “Last updated” date in sync with the dateModified field
Irfan Khan is an experienced writer and researcher with over 6 years of expertise in Manu-related topics. Through ManuLibrary, he shares reliable information, insightful updates, and valuable knowledge to help readers explore, understand, and discover everything about Manu.
