A Like It (5 oz) at Cold Stone Creamery usually costs $5 to $7, a Love It (8 oz) runs $6 to $9, and the biggest cup, the Gotta Have It (12 oz), lands around $8 to $11. Custom ice cream cakes start near $30 for a 6-inch round and climb past $50 for larger sizes. That’s the short answer. Because Cold Stone is almost entirely franchise-owned, your exact total will shift a bit depending on your zip code — but this guide breaks down every category so you know what to expect before you walk up to the counter.
I’ve ordered from Cold Stone locations in three different states over the years, from a strip mall in Ohio to a beach-town shop in Florida, and the pricing swing between them was real — about a dollar and a half difference on the same size cup. This guide for ManuPoint.com pulls together current pricing patterns, portion sizes, and honest opinions on what’s worth ordering, updated for 2026. It’s an independent, unofficial menu guide and isn’t affiliated with Cold Stone Creamery or its parent company, Kahala Brands.
Why Cold Stone Prices Aren’t the Same Everywhere
Cold Stone Creamery doesn’t publish one national price sheet, and that trips people up when they search “Cold Stone menu prices” expecting a fixed number. Nearly every store is an independently owned franchise, so the owner sets local pricing based on rent, local ingredient costs, and competition nearby.
That means a Love It in a small Midwest town might run you $6.50, while the same cup at a mall location in California or a boardwalk shop in New Jersey could hit $9. Hawaii and dense city centers tend to sit at the top of the range. If you’re checking prices before a trip, your safest move is the Cold Stone app or a quick call to the store — the numbers below are solid ballpark figures, not a guarantee.
How we checked this menu. We cross-referenced pricing patterns from the official Cold Stone website and app, in-store visits, and receipts collected across several U.S. markets. Prices, flavors, and availability change often, so treat every figure here as a starting point and confirm current pricing at your nearest store before ordering.
Cold Stone Sizes: Like It, Love It, Gotta Have It
Cold Stone skips the usual small-medium-large labels and uses three named sizes instead. This trips up first-time visitors more than anything else on the menu, so here’s what each one actually means.
| Size | Amount | Typical Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Like It | 5 oz | $5 – $7 | Kids, a light treat, first-time visitors |
| Love It | 8 oz | $6 – $9 | Most people — fits 2 to 3 mix-ins well |
| Gotta Have It | 12 oz | $8 – $11 | Sharing, or a serious sweet tooth |
From ordering these dozens of times, the Love It really is the sweet spot. It’s big enough to taste every mix-in you pick without any of it getting lost, and it doesn’t turn into a melty mess halfway through like the Gotta Have It can if you’re eating outside on a warm day. The Like It is genuinely small — closer to a taste than a full dessert — so I only order it for my nephew or when I’m splitting a Gotta Have It with someone anyway.
One thing worth knowing: standard cups are included in the price, but switching to a waffle cone or waffle bowl usually adds $1 to $2. The waffle bowl is the better upgrade if you’re loading up on hot fudge or caramel, since it holds together better than a cone once things get drippy.
Signature Creations: Cold Stone’s Pre-Built Combos
Signature Creations are Cold Stone’s answer to “I don’t know what to order.” They’re pre-designed flavor and mix-in combinations built by the chain, and ordering one costs the same as building your own — so there’s no real downside to trying one first.
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
This is chocolate ice cream folded with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, peanut butter, and hot fudge, and it’s consistently Cold Stone’s best-selling Creation for good reason. The peanut butter cups stay slightly firm even after mixing, so you get that little bit of chew against the smooth ice cream. If you like anything chocolate-peanut butter, this is the safest order on the whole menu.
Birthday Cake Remix
Birthday cake flavored ice cream gets mixed with brownie pieces, rainbow sprinkles, and whipped topping. It tastes exactly like it sounds — genuinely like eating actual birthday cake in ice cream form, sprinkles and all. It’s the one I see ordered most by families with kids, and it’s a reliable pick if you’re celebrating something.
Founders Favorite
This is the original Creation, dating back to when Cold Stone opened in 1988: sweet cream ice cream with brownie, caramel, pecans, and hot fudge. The pecans add a nice crunch that the other Creations don’t really have, and the caramel keeps it from being too sweet. Order this if you want something less candy-heavy and more like a classic sundae.
Oreo Overload
Sweet cream ice cream loaded with crushed Oreo cookies, Oreo pie crust, and whipped topping. It’s exactly what the name promises — cookies in nearly every bite — and it’s an easy crowd-pleaser if you’re buying for a group where you don’t know everyone’s taste.
Our Strawberry Blonde
Strawberry ice cream blended with graham cracker pie crust, caramel, and whipped topping. This one’s lighter and fruitier than the chocolate-heavy Creations, and it’s my go-to on hot days when I don’t want something too rich.
Mud Pie Mojo
Coffee ice cream mixed with Oreos, peanut butter, roasted almonds, and hot fudge. If you like coffee-flavored desserts, this is one of the few genuinely coffee-forward options on the menu, and the almonds give it a texture the other Creations don’t have.
Apple Pie à la Cold Stone
Cinnamon ice cream folded with cinnamon apples, graham cracker crust, caramel, and whipped topping. It leans seasonal — this is the one to order in fall — and tastes closer to an actual apple pie than you’d expect from ice cream.
Cheesecake Fantasy
Cheesecake ice cream blended with strawberries, graham cracker crust, and whipped topping. It’s tangier than most of the other options, which makes it a good pick if you find the chocolate-based Creations too sweet.
Create Your Own: Flavors and Mix-Ins
If none of the Signature Creations sound right, you can build your own starting with any base flavor. Cold Stone runs over 20 permanent ice cream flavors plus rotating seasonal options, and this is where the “stone” part of the name actually matters — they fold your mix-ins into the ice cream on a frozen granite slab, which blends everything more evenly than a standard scoop shop ever could.
Popular base flavors include Sweet Cream (their most flexible, vanilla-forward base), Chocolate, Cake Batter, Strawberry, Birthday Cake, Coffee, Mint, Cheesecake, and Cotton Candy for the kids.
Mix-ins are priced individually when you go beyond what’s included with your size, and they typically run under a dollar each at most stores. The most-ordered mix-ins, based on Cold Stone’s own sales data, are:
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
- Oreo cookie pieces
- Brownie pieces
- Hot fudge
- Caramel sauce
- Rainbow sprinkles
My honest tip after building plenty of my own cups: stick to 2 to 3 mix-ins. Cold Stone lets you pile on more, but past three flavors the combination starts to muddy together and you lose the point of picking specific ones. A good formula that works almost every time is one chocolate element, one crunchy element like nuts or cookie pieces, and one sauce.
Milkshakes and Smoothies
Cold Stone’s shake menu doesn’t get talked about as much as the Creations, but it’s worth knowing about if you want something you can drink through a straw instead of eating with a spoon.
The Classic Milkshake lets you pick any ice cream flavor blended into a thick shake, with one mix-in included. The PB&C Shake — chocolate ice cream blended with peanut butter — is the most popular shake order and tastes close to a thick peanut butter milkshake you’d get at a diner. The Strawberry Blonde Shake and Coffee Shake round out the lineup, with the coffee version being a solid pick if you want dessert and a caffeine boost in one cup.
For something lighter, Cold Stone also offers smoothies made with real fruit and nonfat yogurt: Berry Berry Good, Mango Berry Madness, and a Peach Smoothie. These are noticeably lower in richness than anything else on the menu and are the closest thing Cold Stone has to a “not dessert” option if you’re craving something cold but don’t want a full ice cream cup.
Ice Cream Cakes: Prices and What to Expect
Cold Stone’s cakes are a real reason people choose them over a grocery store bakery, and they’re a bigger part of the business than most casual customers realize. Every cake is built to order — you pick the ice cream flavor, the mix-ins, and the decoration.
| Cake Size | Serves | Typical Price |
|---|---|---|
| 6-inch round | 6–8 people | $30 – $45 |
| 10-inch round | 12–14 people | $50 – $70 |
| Sheet cake (half/full) | 16–32 people | Price varies by store |
| Ice Cream Cupcakes (4-pack) | Small gatherings | Price varies by store |
The 6-inch is plenty for a small family birthday, and it’s what I’ve ordered most often — it holds up well in the freezer for a day or two if you need to pick it up early. Larger sheet cakes and the 10-inch round make more sense for office parties or bigger celebrations, but they need to be ordered further ahead.
Plan on 24 to 48 hours of advance notice for a custom cake. If you’re in a pinch, some locations keep pre-designed Signature Creation cakes — like a Peanut Butter Cup Perfection Cake — ready in the display case, but availability really depends on the store, so it’s worth calling first.
Calories, Allergen Info, and Dietary Options
Cold Stone isn’t marketed as a light dessert, and the calorie counts reflect that — a Love It with a couple of mix-ins can easily run several hundred calories before you factor in a waffle bowl or extra sauce. Full nutrition and calorie breakdowns are posted on Cold Stone’s official website by item, and I’d recommend checking there directly if calories matter for your order, since portion-based estimates online aren’t always accurate.
For dairy-free options, Cold Stone offers Mango Sorbet and Strawberry Banana Sorbet at most locations. Both skip the dairy base, but keep in mind the kitchen handles dairy constantly, so cross-contact is a real possibility. There’s no certified vegan or gluten-free prep area at Cold Stone, so anyone with a serious allergy should talk to the store manager directly rather than relying on the menu description alone.
Is There a Cold Stone Secret Menu?
Not really — not in the way chains like In-N-Out or Starbucks have one. Cold Stone’s whole model is already built around custom combinations, since you’re choosing your own flavor and mix-ins on nearly every order anyway. If you want something off-script, your best bet is asking staff to combine elements from two Signature Creations, like Peanut Butter Cup Perfection with a scoop of Founders Favorite’s pecans mixed in. Most Cold Stone employees are used to custom requests and are happy to try it.
Best Value Picks and What to Skip
If you’re watching what you spend, a few things I’ve picked up from ordering here regularly:
- Order a Signature Creation instead of overloading a build-your-own. You pay the same either way, and the pre-built combos are genuinely well-balanced.
- Skip extra mix-ins past three. You’re paying more for flavors that mostly cancel each other out.
- The Love It size is the best value per ounce for most appetites — the Like It feels small for the price once you factor in any add-ons.
- Sign up for the My Cold Stone Club app before you order. It’s free, and it gets you a complimentary Like It Creation during your birthday month, along with occasional digital coupons.
- Skip the waffle cone if you’re getting a lot of wet mix-ins like hot fudge or caramel — a cup handles drips far better, and you won’t lose the last bite when the cone gets soggy.
Cold Stone vs. Other Ice Cream Chains
Compared to Dairy Queen and Baskin-Robbins, Cold Stone sits at a higher price point but delivers a noticeably different experience. DQ’s Blizzards are cheaper and faster, usually in the $4 to $6 range for a medium, but you’re picking from a fixed flavor list rather than building your own. Baskin-Robbins offers more rotating flavors at a lower cost per scoop, but it doesn’t have the same mix-in customization or the stone-mixing method that makes Cold Stone’s texture stand out.
If you want speed and a lower price, DQ or Baskin-Robbins will usually win. If you want a fully custom dessert and don’t mind paying a bit more for it, Cold Stone is built for that.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu
Cold Stone Creamery is famous for its frozen granite stone. Staff mix your ice cream and add-ins on it right in front of you. Because of this, the menu feels more like a build-your-own dessert bar than a standard ice cream shop.
The menu has several main parts. First, there are Signature Creations, which are pre-designed flavor combinations. Next, there is Create Your Own, where you pick the ice cream and the mix-ins. In addition, the shop sells shakes, ice cream cakes, cupcakes, cookie sandwiches, and take-home pints.
Here are the core serving prices from a recent menu price listing. The page is dated 2024, so the numbers are approximate.
| Menu item | Like It (small) | Love It (regular) | Gotta Have It (large) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature Creations | $7.49 | $8.05 | $8.65 |
| Create Your Own | $6.35 | $7.35 | $8.25 |
| Shakes | $7.99 | $8.99 | — |
Signature Creations cost slightly more than a custom build. However, they save time, since the recipe is already tested. If you like to control cost, Create Your Own is the cheaper route.
Prices also depend on the franchise owner. A store in a big city mall will usually charge more than one in a small town. Therefore, check the in-store menu board or the official app before you order.
Cold Stone Sizes and Prices
Cold Stone uses its own size names instead of small, medium, and large. The names are fun, but they confuse first-time visitors. Here is what each one means.
- Like It: the small size, ideal for a light treat.
- Love It: the regular size, and the most popular choice.
- Gotta Have It: the large size, built for big appetites or sharing.
For take-home tubs, the shop uses three more names. Mine is a pint, Ours is a quart, and Everybody’s is a triple pint. These sizes work well for family nights and small parties.
| Take-home size | Container | Approx. price |
|---|---|---|
| Mine | Pint | $12.99 |
| Ours | Quart | $17.09 |
| Everybody’s | Triple pint | $21.25 |
The same listing does not give ounce weights for the serving cups. As a result, the size names are the only reliable guide. Meanwhile, the pint, quart, and triple pint prices apply to both Signature flavors and Mix & Go builds.
Here is a simple tip. If two people want dessert, one Gotta Have It often costs less than two Like It cups. On the other hand, if you want to try two flavors, two small cups give you more variety.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Reddit
Many shoppers check Reddit before they visit. The forums are a popular place to ask whether Cold Stone is worth the money. The conversation tends to repeat a few themes.
First, people often say the price is high compared with a regular ice cream scoop shop. Second, they note that mix-ins and extra toppings can raise the bill. Finally, many mention that prices differ a lot between stores, because each location is run by its own franchise owner.
On the positive side, fans praise the fresh mixing and the huge range of combinations. For example, many say the cake batter and cookie dough flavors justify the cost on special days. Others suggest it is best as an occasional treat rather than a weekly habit.
These are general patterns, not exact quotes. Prices and opinions shift quickly, so read recent threads for your own city.
Here are some money-saving ideas that shoppers commonly share:
- Order Create Your Own instead of a Signature Creation.
- Pick a Like It size and add only one or two mix-ins.
- Check the app or the store for coupons and loyalty offers.
- Buy a cake or party pack when feeding a group, since the per-person cost drops.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cold Stone Creamery expensive?
Cold Stone Creamery is generally more expensive than many regular ice cream shops because of its premium flavors and mix-ins. Prices vary by location, serving size, and toppings, with specialty creations usually costing more. It is a good choice for customers who enjoy customized ice cream and generous combinations of ingredients.
How much are Cold Stone ice cream prices?
Cold Stone ice cream prices vary depending on the size, flavor, and type of dessert you order. A basic serving may cost a few dollars, while signature creations, waffle cones, and larger sizes cost more. Check your local Cold Stone Creamery menu for the most accurate and current prices.
How much is Cold Stone ice cream by size?
Cold Stone typically offers Like It, Love It, and Gotta Have It sizes for its signature creations. Like It is the smallest, Love It is the medium option, and Gotta Have It is the largest. Prices increase with serving size, and exact amounts depend on the store and selected dessert.
How much is a cup of ice cream at Cold Stone?
A small cup of Cold Stone ice cream may cost around $5–$7, depending on the location and flavor. Medium and large signature creations generally cost more, especially when they include premium mix-ins. For exact prices, check the official Cold Stone Creamery menu.
Menu
+1
How much does Cold Stone Creamery cost?
A typical Cold Stone ice cream creation may cost approximately $5–$10 before tax, depending on its size and ingredients. Shakes, ice cream cakes, and larger desserts can cost considerably more than a basic serving. Your final bill depends on the menu items, extras, and local store prices.
livemenuprices.com
+1
How much is one scoop of ice cream?
One small serving of Cold Stone ice cream typically costs around $5–$7 in the United States. Adding a waffle cone or extra toppings may increase the total price. Prices vary by location, so check your nearest store for its current single-serving price.
Business Insider
+1
Disclaimer: This is an independent, unofficial guide created by ManuPoint.com. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Cold Stone Creamery or Kahala Brands. Prices, menu items, and availability vary by location, franchise ownership, and season — always confirm current pricing at your nearest Cold Stone Creamery or through the official Cold Stone app before ordering.
Final thoughts
Cold Stone is a premium dessert, but the menu gives you ways to control the cost. Choose a smaller size, build your own mix, or buy a cake for a crowd. Before ordering, confirm prices with your local store.
Irfan Khan is an experienced writer and researcher with over 6 years of expertise in Manu-related topics. Through ManuLibrary, he shares reliable information, insightful updates, and valuable knowledge to help readers explore, understand, and discover everything about Manu.
